“When I was 8 years old, I went to my best friend’s sleepover party with about 5 other people….

“When I was 8 years old, I went to my best friend’s sleepover party with about 5 other people. At night, we decided to play murder in the dark (If you don’t know the rules of the game it’s basically hide and seek) and I was the person who was ‘it’. 

I was walking through their living room when one of the people playing crawls out from under the cupboard and basically just acts like everything is fine. I say, ‘I found you.’ They seem really confused and say, ‘But you found everyone already.’ I tell them that they were the first person I had found. 

Now here’s the creepy part. They say that they only crawled out from under the cupboard because someone, they did not know who, whispered to them this: ‘[deleted] has found everyone. You can come out now.’ 

We asked everyone in the household if they had whispered it, or if they knew who. It is about 6 years later and we still do not know who did it.”

By: [deleted] 

(What creepy story have you never been
able fully to explain?
)